(Post update September 2017)
A few months ago, I got call from a guy named Clark Valberg.
Now aside from being an all around awesome guy, Clark also turned out to be the Co-Founder and CEO of InVision.
If you don’t know about InVision yet, then it’s time that you check them out. InVision is a design prototyping and collaboration platform used by over 2,000,000 graphic designers and their teams (Including companies like AirBnB, LinkedIn, Evernote, and many more).
Despite the company’s huge overall success, Clark and his team were having a really hard time generating more signups via Facebook ads.
When InVision hired me to manage Facebook ads for them, they had two primarily goals…
First, to bring down their cost per new signup and second, to scale the campaign up to generate as many low cost, high quality signups as possible.
Working together with one of InVision’s extremely talented designers, we came up with a number of great ad concepts to test (examples below).
But as I always tell my clients, the secret to Facebook success lies in proper campaign structuring, segmentation, bid management and testing.
Here is a list of four techniques that really worked well for me on the InVision campaign…
1) Lookalike Audiences
I love Lookalike audiences!
Lookalike audiences eliminate a lot of the guess work in building target audiences by letting you targeting people who are similar to your current customers.
The hard part though is finding the right data source to build your lookalike audience from. Simply uploading your customer emails and building a Lookalike audience from it is usually not enough to build a high converting audience.
For our experience working with lots of SaaS startups, we’ve found that Lookalikes based on people who triggered your primiary conversion event are usually the most effective. So for InVision, we built a Lookalike based on all people who signed up for a free trial and triggered the Complete Registration event.
They key to building an effective Lookalike is to balance the size and relevancy of your base audience. You want to start with an audience of high value users (ideally paying customers). But you also want to make sure that your audience has at least a few thousand people in it.
And don’t forget about excluded audiences either. Make sure you exclude custom audiences of people who have already converted on your site.
If you’re already paying to get traffic to your website from lots of different sources, then make sure not to let those people get away without them signing up or buying. Your retargeting list is usually the most high converting audience you can hit so take advantage of it.
In fact, in the case of InVision, the average cost per signup via retargeting was about 23% cheaper than signups from other campaigns.
3) Use the Right Side Column
Update Sept 2017: Since this article was first written, Facebook has introduced a lot of new ad placements including Instagram. It’s important to test different placements for each company to figure out what works best for you.
When working with InVision we generated conversions from right side ads for an average cost that was about 41% lower than desktop newsfeed ads. Today, we’re not seeing those same results. However, Instagram has been a very effective ad placement even for B2B SaaS companies.
If you’re working with a small budget, right side ads can be a great way to stretch your budget and get good results.
4) Dark Color Ads
As a general rule, it’s important to test a lot of different image creatives in all your campaigns. For the InVision campaigns, we found that using a semi-transparent dark gray layer over images tends to help them perform much better. I think the dark color stands out bold on in people’s Newsfeeds.
UPDATE: However for most of our clients at the end of 2017, we are finding that this dark style ad is no longer working.
Lately, we’ve had great success creating ads that don’t look like ads. Our goal with our new ads is to make ads that look more like content posts. These ads tend to get much higher CTR and lower CPC. Here’s a great example of an ad that looks like content that has done well for use (you can read more about how we create this style ad here).
Recommended Reading: 10 Examples of Facebook Ads for SaaS
Here are a few examples of successful ad creatives that we ran for InVision.
And here’s another one…
By the second month of the campaign, I succeeded in reducing InVision’s average cost per new signup on Facebook by 44% compared to the results they got from the previous agency that had been managing their Facebook campaigns.
Next, it was time to start cranking up the budget to increase the daily volume of new signups. After another week of tweaking, I found the sweet spot for my daily budget that provided approximately 1100% more signups per month than InVision had previously been generating on Facebook.
Now it’s your turn…
What’s working for you in your Facebook ad campaigns? Let me know in the comments below.
If you’re still struggling to get these kinds of results from your Facebook ads (or if you know somebody else who needs help), then be sure to check out my Facebook Ads Consulting services and let’s work together to create this kind of success for you.
- Podcast #30 – How to Attribute B2B Marketing Activities to Revenue with Steffen Hedebrandt - February 27, 2023
- Podcast #29 – Nick Jordan’s B2B SEO Strategies to Rank #1 without Backlinks - December 1, 2022
- Podcast #28 – How OptiMonk uses Customer Value Optimization to drive more sales with Eric Melchor - November 21, 2022
10 thoughts on “[Case Study] How We Reduced InVision’s Cost Per Signup with Facebook Ads by 44%”
Lookalike audiences have absolutely been the bread & butter when it comes to cutting CPAs for my clients!
Just remember you’ll want to narrow it down from the super broad and wide reach of the lookalike alone. After you create the lookalike audience, fill out the interest targeting (and like you said, exclude exclude exclude!)
Great point Vincent!
Lookalike nesting is great as well.. creating 5 ad sets for each lookalike in the following way (1% , 3%-1% , 5%-3% , 7%-5% , 9%-7%)
That’s true. I often use a strategy like that when I use a broader lookalike audience. Unfortunately, I’ve usually found that when I jump from 1% to 2% lookalike the results aren’t nearly as good.
Same for us Aaron. 1% seems to win consistently and once we go beyond that it doesn’t seem to work as well.
We have had success leaving the audience wide open with no Lookalike or interests and just optimize off the conversion pixel. Audience is 48 million in size and working well.
Aaron, great job here. Tell me, do you still stand by ‘Dark Color Ads’ being more effective? You wrote this post more than a year ago and i’d love to hear how things have developed in relation to this.
Great question Marc! These types of ads don’t work very well on FB anymore because people quickly recognize them as ads and ignore them. Today, the key to creating Facebook ads that get noticed is to make ads that don’t look like ads. Make your ads look like content. I’ll be writing a lot more on this topic in the coming weeks so make sure you’re on my email list to get notified.
Which type of campaign would work for legal tech firm? Which is highly competitive these days in US. Suggest something.
Tough question Richa. I would probably think about using Lead Ads. But it’s a tricky question that needs a proper strategy.
Pingback: How the World’s Fastest Growing SaaS Companies Scale Facebook Ads